One would think that we’d come far enough in our business lives to outgrow old fashioned means of sharing critical business information  While we don’t necessarily need to utilize the latest and greatest technologies, you’d think we’d at least get out of the dark ages.  Unfortunately we keep slipping back into the past.

What am I talking about?  I found that the lunacy that has taken hold in the high-tech space has oozed into retail.  Yes, my pet peeve, replacing B2B transactions with manual portals, has invaded retail.  Suppliers to the retailer in question know it well.  The retailer has eschewed common sense and asked their suppliers to manually enter ALL product data via a portal.  No option is given for uploading data.  This from a company once a leader in usage of electronic file transfers for product data.

Now, this may not be so bad if it weren’t for the fact that the data being entered includes data for apparel products.  Think about it.  All the different sizes, colors, styles, etc.  And these products are usually seasonal, so all this information is entered once for just a few orders. 

Suppliers have had to hire extensive teams just to provide the product data to this company, or that data gets provided slowly and late.  The competition must be smiling over this one.  A once proud and strong company jettisons industry leading processes and tries to compete, using a manual portal, with retailers small and large who have automated these processes in order to speed new product introduction, ensure accurate ordering, enhance the chance that orders will be fulfilled in a timely fashion, and to reduce costs.  This retailer is increasing their costs, introducing errors, minimizing their chance for accurate and timely delivery and more.  I also understand that from some suppliers they receive product up to 7 weeks after the competition – not good for products with a seasonal sales cycle.

But how and why is this happening?  Perhaps a loss of institutional knowledge is the key.  An IT team with little experience in the apparel B2B space is probably part of this company’s problem.  Loss of institutional knowledge is a problem that many companies will face – to their own detriment – as we move forward.  Mergers and acquisitions may create some of these situations, but the sense I’m getting from a few smart resources is that B2B staff members are becoming increasingly grey in their hair.  This means as people are promoted, let go, or retire, companies will be left with young, inexperienced people with no understanding of technicalities of transaction management or mapping, little knowledge of the subtleties of trading partner management, and no sense of history when it comes to the long row we’ve hoed in the EDI fields over the last 30+ years.  Taking the quick and dirty way out to put up a portal may reduce IT costs, but it increases overall business costs substantially.

An AMR analyst noted to me earlier this year that there is a lack of university and other formal educational programs focused on B2B here in the US.  There is also a dearth of reasonably available industry B2B training.  This means that folks with little experience are being handed the keys to the corporate B2B infrastructures and finding the easiest way out – building portals and then telling the suppliers to stop the antiquated electronic messaging so they can use the cool, manual web forms with a dancing mouse on them.  Ok, I made up the dancing mouse part. 

As I’ve mentioned previously in this blog, I think portals are great for trading relationships where one company is unable or unwilling to automate, but for heaven’s sake, if you can execute automated transactions, do so.  The tough thing for most inexperienced people to understand when tossed into an EDI role is that the goal of B2B is to support the best execution of the business.  Unfortunately if they fail to understand legal and operational requirements, if they get caught up in technical rather than functional needs, they can end up “executing” the operation of the business (pun intended).  Unfortunately, I know from experience that this lesson is lost on many executives as well, so the real danger comes when the bad decisions from the inexperienced in the B2B role are supported by, rather than questioned by, the members of the C-suite.